Oklahoma Sex Crimes and the Robyn Polston Case: What Could Happen Here?

Recent national coverage from outlets such as Daily Mail and People describes accusations that an Illinois mother, Robyn Polston, chaperoned her daughter’s junior high dance, then allegedly started a sexual relationship with her daughter’s 14-year-old date and later gave birth to his child. She reportedly faces multiple counts of criminal sexual assault and possession of child pornography in Illinois.

Stories like this raise an obvious question for Oklahomans: what Oklahoma sex crimes could apply if similar facts happened here? This post breaks down how a scenario like the one described in the Robyn Polston case might intersect with Oklahoma’s rape, child sexual abuse, lewd acts, and child pornography statutes—and why anyone under investigation needs an experienced Oklahoma criminal defense lawyer immediately.

Summary of the Allegations in the Robyn Polston Case

According to media reports, investigators in Illinois allege that a 43-year-old mother:

• Chaperoned a junior high dance her daughter attended in May 2023.
• Her daughter’s 14-year-old date later became the alleged victim.
• The mother allegedly began a sexual relationship with the boy after the dance.
• She gave birth in January 2025; the baby reportedly shares the boy’s middle and last name.
• DNA testing allegedly confirmed the teen as the baby’s father.
• Authorities say they recovered sexually explicit images and videos involving the mother and the boy.

Illinois prosecutors have reportedly charged her with multiple counts of criminal sexual assault involving a minor between 13 and 17 and multiple counts of possession of child pornography, and some reports indicate she could face decades in prison if convicted.

Again, these are allegations. The case will turn on the evidence and how the Illinois courts interpret and apply their law. But it provides a useful lens to discuss what might happen under Oklahoma law if similar allegations arose here.

How Similar Allegations Would Be Viewed Under Oklahoma Law

Oklahoma has some of the toughest laws in the country when it comes to sexual conduct involving minors. Several different Oklahoma statutes could be implicated by a fact pattern similar to the one described in the Robyn Polston case.

Rape and Statutory Rape in Oklahoma

Under Oklahoma law, “rape” is broadly defined at 21 O.S. § 1111. When an adult has sexual intercourse with a minor who is under the age of legal consent, it can be charged as statutory rape—regardless of whether the minor appeared to agree to the sexual activity.

Depending on the specific facts (such as the ages of the people involved and any aggravating factors), an Oklahoma prosecutor could consider:

• Rape in the First Degree – typically the most serious rape charge, which can apply when certain aggravating circumstances or very young victims are involved under Oklahoma law.
• Rape in the Second Degree – which can apply in other situations where the law deems the minor incapable of giving legal consent to intercourse with an adult.

Even one count of rape in Oklahoma can expose a person to a very substantial prison sentence, potential lifetime registration as a sex offender, and a permanent felony record.

Child Sexual Abuse and Enabling Child Sexual Abuse

Oklahoma’s child abuse statute at 21 O.S. § 843.5 is extremely broad. It criminalizes not only physical abuse and neglect but also child sexual abuse by a person responsible for the child’s health, safety, or welfare. That includes parents, guardians, and other caretakers.

In a scenario where a parent allegedly engages in sexual intercourse or other sexual acts with a minor, Oklahoma prosecutors could look at charges such as:

Conviction for child sexual abuse under this statute can carry a maximum penalty of up to life in prison, along with significant fines and other consequences.

Lewd or Indecent Acts with a Child Under 16

Separate from rape, Oklahoma has a specific crime for lewd or indecent acts with a child under sixteen at 21 O.S. § 1123. This statute can cover a wide range of conduct, including lewd touching, exposure, or other sexual behavior involving a child.

In a case where an adult allegedly grooms a minor, sends explicit messages, or engages in sexual contact that might not fit neatly into the rape statute, prosecutors sometimes charge lewd acts in addition to or instead of rape. Multiple counts are possible if there are multiple alleged acts or digital communications.

Oklahoma Child Pornography and Sexual Exploitation Laws

The news coverage of the Robyn Polston matter also mentions sexually explicit images and videos allegedly involving the adult and the teen. If similar allegations arose in Oklahoma, prosecutors could look to Oklahoma’s child pornography and sexual exploitation laws, including:

• Sexual Exploitation of Children, which can cover creating or causing the creation of sexually explicit material involving minors. 21 O.S. § 1021.2
• Aggravated Possession of Child Pornography, which can apply when a person possesses large quantities of child pornography or particularly serious material. 21 O.S. § 1040.12a

Charges under these statutes can bring additional felony counts on top of any rape or lewd acts charges, further increasing the potential prison exposure.

Key Oklahoma Issues Highlighted by the Polston Allegations

1. Minors Cannot Legally Consent to Sex with Adults

One of the biggest misconceptions people have about sex crimes involving minors is the idea that “the kid wanted it” or “it was a relationship.” Under Oklahoma law, that is not a defense when the child is under the age of consent.

Even if the facts suggest that a minor appeared to voluntarily participate, the law treats the minor as legally incapable of consent in statutory rape and many child sexual abuse situations. That is why, in Oklahoma, statements like “but we were in love” or “the child agreed” do not end the case—they can actually be used as evidence by the prosecution. Not knowing the age of the accuser is not a defense.

2. Digital Evidence and Burner Phones

News reports in the Robyn Polston case mention burner phones, alleged attempts to hide identities, and sexually explicit images and videos. In modern sex-crime cases, Oklahoma law enforcement agencies often focus heavily on:

• Cell phone extractions and text messages.
• Social media messages and DMs.
• Cloud backups, email, and messaging apps.
• Photos, videos, and metadata.

Because digital evidence can be complex and sometimes misleading, a strong defense in Oklahoma often involves challenging how that evidence was obtained, interpreted, and presented to the jury.

3. DNA Evidence and Paternity

In the Illinois case, media outlets report that investigators used DNA testing to confirm the alleged victim as the baby’s father. In Oklahoma, DNA evidence can play a similar role if a pregnancy is involved. But DNA only proves biological relationship—it does not automatically prove whether a crime occurred or what the circumstances were.

An Oklahoma criminal defense lawyer may explore issues such as:

• How the DNA samples were collected and preserved.
• Chain of custody and lab procedures.
• Alternative explanations or timelines for conception.

Possible Defenses in an Oklahoma Sex Crimes Case

Every case is unique, and The Urbanic Law Firm builds defenses based on the specific facts and charges. In a complex Oklahoma sex crimes case involving allegations similar to those in the Robyn Polston story, potential defense strategies might include:

• Challenging the alleged timeline of the relationship or conception.
• Attacking the reliability of witness statements, especially if they come from emotionally charged family situations.
• Filing motions to suppress unlawfully obtained phone or computer evidence.
• Disputing the interpretation of digital messages or photos.
• Arguing that the evidence does not meet the elements of specific Oklahoma statutes like 21 O.S. §§ 1113, 1123, or 843.5.

The sooner a defense attorney is involved, the more options there typically are to protect your rights and shape the trajectory of the case.

Why Contact Urbanic Law Firm if You Are Under Investigation in Oklahoma?

Stories like the Robyn Polston case show how quickly a situation can escalate from rumor or a tip to an intensive criminal investigation. In Oklahoma, you do not have to be formally charged before you seek legal representation—and waiting can hurt you.

The Urbanic Law Firm is a criminal defense law firm based in Oklahoma City that focuses on defending people accused of serious crimes, including sex offenses involving minors. Our team can:

• Advise you about whether to talk to law enforcement (and when to stay silent).
• Communicate with detectives and prosecutors on your behalf.
• Help you understand what Oklahoma statutes you may be facing.
• Work to protect your freedom, your reputation, and your future.

If you learn that you are being investigated for any sex crime in Oklahoma—or if you have already been arrested—do not wait to get help.

Call Urbanic Law Firm today at 405-633-3420 or request a free case evaluation online.

Oklahoma Sex Crimes FAQs

What Oklahoma sex crimes could apply if an adult has a baby with a 14-year-old?

In Oklahoma, prosecutors could consider charges such as rape defined in 21 O.S. §§ 1111, 1111.1 and 1113, child sexual abuse under 21 O.S. § 843.5 and lewd or indecent acts with a child under 21 O.S. § 1123, depending on the facts.

Is consent a defense to statutory rape charges in Oklahoma?

No. Under Oklahoma law, a minor under 18 (in most cases) cannot legally consent to sexual intercourse with an adult, so an alleged victim’s apparent consent is not a legal defense to statutory rape charges.

What are the possible penalties for rape in the second degree in Oklahoma?

Rape in the second degree in Oklahoma is a felony that can carry a lengthy prison sentence, registration as a sex offender and other serious consequences, though the exact range depends on the statutes in effect and the person’s prior record.

Can Oklahoma prosecutors file both rape and lewd acts charges in the same case?

Yes. If the evidence shows separate criminal acts, Oklahoma prosecutors may file multiple counts, including rape charges and lewd or indecent acts with a child, but the defense can challenge whether the charges are supported by distinct conduct.

Why should I contact an Oklahoma sex crimes defense lawyer right away?

Early representation by an experienced Oklahoma sex crimes defense lawyer helps protect your rights, manage police contact, preserve favorable evidence and start building a defense before charges are filed.

Contact The Urbanic Law Firm

If you’ve been charged with rape, lewd acts with a minor, or any other criminal offense in Oklahoma, contact The Urbanic Law Firm today. Call 405-633-3420 or fill out our form.
Based in Oklahoma City and serving clients statewide.

This page is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique; consult an attorney about your specific situation. Page last updated November 6,, 2025. Consult the statutes listed above for the most up-to-date law.